Bible Readings for Saturday, June 4th, 2011 – The 7th Week of Easter
*Click on each bible passage to expand the text.
…Unless You Believe…
Today, we consider yet another staple passage which, for many Christians, justifies why you must believe in Jesus to be saved.
John 8
24. ” I told you that you would die in your sins, for you will die in your sins unless you believe that I am he.”
It is passages like this that help make Christianity about “belief” and not “faith”, about exclusion and not inclusion, about your own personal salvation and not the world’s.
This passage essentially contradicts the rest of Jesus’ message throughout his ministry: “Kingdom Here, Kingdom Now, Kingdom Come“. The language of his Kingdom parables and sayings clearly puts the emphasis on the here and now, and the salvation of the community. Contrast that with John 8:24, which seems to put the emphasis on the future and on the salvation of the individual.
However, as we discovered in my post about the nuances of translation found in John 14:6, it seems that much of the mystical language and insight of the Greek Gospel of John has been translated out in English (be it purposefully or accidentally). I find this revelation to be tragic. In my life as a Christian, the Gospel of John has become one of the most insightful and informative books for my inclusive and loving faith. However, the Christian “fundamentalists” often use this very book to justify their exclusive, judgmental, and individualistic morality. And this is only possible with the neutered meaning of many of the key passages of John.
Once again, in John 8:24, if we examine the nuances of the Greek, we find surprising shifts in meaning:
John 8:24
εἶπον οὖν ὑμῖν ὅτι ἀποθανεῖσθε ἐν ταῖς ἁμαρτίαις ὑμῶν· ἐὰν γὰρ μὴ πιστεύσητε ὅτι ἐγὼ εἰμι, ἀποθανεῖσθε ἐν ταῖς ἁμαρτίαις ὑμῶν.
Therefore I told you, you will die away from God because of your own missing the mark, however if you trust in what I AM, you will not miss the mark and die away from God.
“I AM” not “he”
The first thing that jumped out at me when I looked at the Greek is there is no “he” (unless you believe that I am he). The translators insisted on adding the “he”, when leaving out the he allows us to make allusion to God’s Hebrew name, I AM.
Trust vs. Belief
Secondly, I prefer to use the faith/trust translation of the Greek πιστεύσητε (4100, pisteusēte), and not “believe”. Believe has lost much of it’s nuance in modern culture and has become simply a “yes/no” statement if something is “true” or not.
If a husband asks his wife if she “believes in him”, what is he asking? He’s asking if she trusts him.
If someone asks you to “have a little faith in me”, they are asking you to trust in them.
And yet Christians across the world insist Jesus means for us to “believe” in his divinity. Yes/no, cut and dried. This insistence leaves us with a neutered understanding of pisteusēte.
Is Jesus the I AM, and therefore divine? Yes. But is that divinity exclusive? No at all, it is inclusive:
Isaiah 44
6. “I AM the First and the Last; there is no other God..
Whether Jesus is the real God is not his question. Jesus is asking us to trust in I AM, and what I AM is begging us to do.
Death vs. Spiritual Death
Lastly, the English translations all translate ἀποθανεῖσθε (599, apothnéskó) as “to die, dead”. However, thnéskó (2348) means to “die”, and apo (575) means “away from”. So it is clear that the English translation is lacking in meaning, especially because apothnéskó always implies a divine aspect as well!
There is such a vast difference in meaning between “dying” and “dying away from God”. One implies life ends, too, the other implies the quality of one’s life changes. Some might say, “Great! If I don’t trust in God, all that happens is I die from God? Count me in, that sounds easy enough!”, however, I caution those who are cynical from assuming there is ease where there is really great suffering. Look around you. The world today is filled with people who don’t “trust” God. And this world can be a very dark and heartless world, full of trouble.
The cynics of the world toss off spiritual death like it’s nothing. However, only when you climb out of spiritual death again do you finally realize how oppressive it really was.
Sin vs. Missing the Mark
Sin (266, hamartia) really means “missing the mark”. It is a self-imposed failure, never by God. Essentially we choose to miss the mark. It isn’t inborn, like a genetic flaw. It is of our own creation and responsibility.
What does Jesus teach we miss the mark about? Greed. Love for others. Empathy. Selflessness. Sacrifice. Inclusiveness. Not a word about missing prayer, about not going to church, or about reading the wrong books.
The best thing about understanding sin as “missing the mark” is the realization that you can always take aim again, and hit the mark.
Trust in What Jesus Is
So, what are we to trust in? What is Jesus?
Jesus is I AM the only God there ever was or will be, and Jesus is the Word of I AM. Trust in the Word of I AM, and you will not die away from God anymore.
And what can the Word of God through Jesus be boiled down to?
Matthew 22
37. And he said to him, “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. 38. This is the great and first commandment.
39. And a second is like it: You shall love your neighbor as yourself.
40. On these two commandments depend all the Law and the Prophets.”
So, how are you doing on “missing the mark”?
Me? I’m just thankful I can re-shoot!


Love this. Thanks.
Your support, as always, means the world to me, Tana.
This is great stuff, Trig. I never learned any of this growing up in the United Methodist church. It’s essays like this that are so helpful to me in gaining a far deeper understanding of Christian faith.
Thank YOU, Tracie. I’m so grateful that you read it and enjoyed it.
Excellent analysis. Dr. Lynn Bauman, who co-authored The Luminous Gospels, told us that the original translators of the KJV almost always selected the harshest possible meanings of the Latin words. It seems very clear to me that Jeshua was a part of the Jewish mystical wisdom tradition, but much of what he actually taught was intentionally excluded at the Council of Nicea so that what was included made it easier for Constantine and his successors to control the populations.
Great comment, Gary! Fear puts butts in the seats and votes in the ballot box. Love promotes change and topples empires.